| Platinum | Kia of Cheyenne |
| Gold | Ken Garff Toyota Cheyenne |
| Silver | Kustom Illusions |
| Bronze | Big O Tires |
| Top Pick | Ars Inc-Automotive Repair Specialists |
| Top Pick | Big Al's Auto & Exhaust |
| Top Pick | Cheyenne Auto Repair Service |
| Top Pick | Sappbros Service Center |
| Top Pick | T and T Auto Center |
| Top Pick | The Brake Stop |